If someone asked me to describe Erdoğan, if they asked, “How do you know him, how do you see him?”, I could perhaps talk for hours. Or maybe I could explain it in a single sentence. The sentence that matters, both for me and for Turkey, is this: he should not keep deceiving people and then come out saying, “I was deceived.”
Whenever Erdoğan is mentioned, Sülün Osman immediately comes to mind. He too was someone who deceived people. But there is an important difference between them: Sülün Osman does not say “I was deceived”; he tells you how he deceived others. As a journalist who conducted the last interview with Sülün Osman, I can say this comfortably. Their similarity lies in deception; the difference is that Sülün Osman boasts about it, while Erdoğan says “I was deceived” after every incident.
At a certain point, doesn’t saying “I was deceived” amount to calling yourself an idiot? If I am deceived this often, shouldn’t I say, “I am an idiot. What do you want from me? Leave me alone”?
In the old days, children and grandchildren tended to trick their grandparents rather than their fathers and mothers — because they did not quite have the nerve for the latter, and neither would we. They took advantage of the generation gap and of events the older generation had not lived through. Erdoğan, however, is a complete specialist in this; a specialist in deception who constantly says, “I was deceived.”
So what are the cases in which Erdoğan says he was deceived? Let us use his own full sentences.
Regarding 17-25 December, he says: “We were deceived; we were truly naïve.” But this is interesting. When you listen to him speaking with Bilal on the phone, you understand that he was not deceived. They discuss how the people’s money was taken, how it was obtained, how it was kept at home, and what should now be done with that money. Bilal’s difficulty in understanding what his father is telling him is another part of the story.
Then he turns to the Gülen movement and says again, “We were deceived; we were truly naïve.” In other words, it is as if he is saying: we thought they would keep this secret; we set out on this road together, we deceived these people together, but now they are telling everyone that I deceived them.
The period when an investigation was opened into Hakan Fidan, then head of the MİT, is also important. Erdoğan tells Bülent Arınç, who is in the United States and is going to meet Fethullah Gülen: “I cannot come; I have a lot of work. Do they have an order for me, an order for us? Do they have any criticism? Find out.” Everyone thinks relations with the Gülen movement broke down after the Hakan Fidan affair. No, he is still waiting for instructions.
Again, at a rally in Uşak on 27 February, speaking about the Gülen structure, he says: “We are being deceived, we were deceived. Even I was deceived.” In other words: “Even I am an idiot.”
When the AKP was first founded, it did not have enough cadres in the bureaucracy. A significant part of the bureaucrats from the Milli Görüş tradition had remained with Saadet or within the Refah line. The AKP relied on the Gülen movement at this point. And from its own point of view, the Gülen movement took advantage of this opportunity, “rightfully” in quotation marks.
In 2015, Erdoğan had said of the Ergenekon and Balyoz trials, “I am their prosecutor.” He and Kılıçdaroğlu stood on opposing sides over this issue. Then, on 19 March 2015, Erdoğan said: “Through these operations, the entire country, myself first and foremost, was misdirected and deceived.”
Fine, let us say you yourself were deceived; but why do you declare that the entire nation was deceived? How exactly were the people deceived in Ergenekon and Balyoz? We never understood that. You are the ones who appointed those commanders. You are the ones who selected them in the Supreme Military Council. You are the ones holding those meetings.
It is true that there was not usually much interference in the Supreme Military Council, but there were examples even before Erdoğan. I had talked about Bülent Ecevit, for instance. Kenan Evren, who should have retired after his post in İzmir, was moved ahead of Nurettin Ersin, with one or two people sacrificed along the way, on the grounds that “This man is very democratic”; his retirement was prevented and he was made Chief of the General Staff.
How do I know Nurettin Ersin was ahead of Kenan Evren? From my father. Nurettin Ersin was my father’s classmate at military school. I do not know how serious he was, but my father used to say with a laugh: “I wish I had not let him copy. I wish I had not given that guy the answers.” Maybe he really did. Things like that happen in military schools.
“The entire country, myself first and foremost, was misdirected.” Misdirected toward what? After the trial had already begun? From the very beginning, I wrote dozens of articles saying, “If you make one coup group, or two coup groups, this large, you make it almost certain that the case will end in acquittal.”
On 20 April 2017, speaking about US policy toward the PYD and YPG, he says: “Unfortunately, Obama deceived us on the issue of the PYD and YPG.” Deceived once again.
On 26 September 2017, it is Barzani’s turn. Turkey erupts over Barzani’s independence referendum. All the nationalists, including Devlet Bahçeli, who today is pushing for a peace table and a handshake, were saying very different things at the time. Erdoğan, however, says: “We did not think Barzani would make such a mistake. It seems we were wrong.”
Deceived again. This time by Barzani. I do not know whether Erdoğan has a master’s degree or even a university diploma, but he could certainly do a master’s in deception.
Regarding another operational plan during the Obama era, he also says: “Unfortunately, Obama deceived us there.” I will not go into the details; that is not what this programme is about. But Obama deceived him twice. He does not count what Trump did. Calling him “stupid” and all the rest — at least Trump says such things to his face.
On 14 July 2021, he returns once again to the Gülen movement. This time he speaks about the exploitation of religion: “For years they exploited the sacredness of our religion. I say it openly: we were deceived.”
One moment. This is very important.
Erdoğan, don’t you know religion very well? Didn’t they teach you religion at imam-hatip school? Or did you suddenly forget everything you learned there when, in your final year, you transferred to Eyüp High School in order to get into university?
How can someone who conducts so much politics through religion and claims to know religion say, “For years they exploited the sacredness of our religion. I say it openly: we were deceived”? How did you believe this? How could you be deceived so easily through a religious order? It is not easy either to explain or to understand.
On 3 August 2016, he says: “May my Lord forgive us, and may my nation forgive us.” The word “deceived” is not used here, but the meaning is clear. In at least seven separate speeches, Erdoğan says that he was deceived.
So who else deceived Erdoğan?
Let us look at the split between Abdullah Gül and Erdoğan. Gül was once someone Erdoğan called “my closest friend.” Erdoğan had sent him to the presidency. At the time, I had a friend whose name I will not give who knew the events of that period very closely. He was in frequent contact with both the Gül family and the Erdoğan family.
When Gül was made the presidential candidate, it is said that Emine Erdoğan also reacted negatively. Because the First Lady would no longer be her, but Hayrünnisa Gül. Most likely, the beginning of the rift between Erdoğan and Gül coincided with the beginning of the rift between Emine Erdoğan and Hayrünnisa Gül.
The families were so close that when Abdullah Gül became president and the Çankaya Palace was being renovated, he stayed in Foreign Ministry accommodation. Even though Emine Erdoğan and Hayrünnisa Gül had fallen out, it appears that the children continued to see one another.
It is said that Burak Erdoğan could send away the workers doing renovations there by saying, “Come on, off you go, we are going to have fun with friends.” Nobody objected. It is claimed that people knew Burak Erdoğan drank alcohol and used similar substances and did not live a particularly devout life. It is further alleged that this created a fear that one day he might reveal certain things within the family. It is said that one reason the Gül family was kept somewhat at a distance from the Erdoğan family and was given more assignments abroad was connected to this.
Was he the only one? Ahmet Davutoğlu also supposedly deceived Erdoğan through certain laws he wanted to introduce. There is Ali Babacan. At the very beginning there was Abdüllatif Şener. And Bülent Arınç is another name who, despite being among the founders of that period, had very serious differences with Erdoğan.
So here we have a person who is always being deceived. How can that be?
If you look for a similar example in Turkish politics, Tansu Çiller comes to mind. A politician who both deceived others and was herself deceived.
According to Cüneyt Arcayürek in the newspaper Cumhuriyet dated 3 April 1999, Mesut Yılmaz says of a political agreement made with Çiller and the DYP: “She deceived me, and yes, we were deceived.” This is not a direct recording of a conversation; it is an account reported by Arcayürek.
After mutual acquittals in parliamentary investigation files, a change to the immunity arrangement is expected. Yılmaz says that the DYP later refused to support the change and that Çiller deceived him.
With Demirel, Ecevit, Özal or Erbakan, there was no constant politics of “I was deceived” like there is with Erdoğan. But of course there are other stories of deception.
One of them is the Selçuk Parsadan affair from the Tansu Çiller era. Parsadan introduces himself as retired General Necdet Öztorun, imitates his voice, and during the Çiller period obtains 5.5 billion from the secret fund. He is later convicted over the affair. Here, there really is deception.
There is Jet Fadıl. There is “Tosuncuk” Mehmet Aydın. There is Titan. There is Güney Zobu, known as Rocky. Another old fraud story in Turkey is Eyüplü Halit. He is known for posing as a police official and taking people’s money with promises of marriage.
This too is interesting. In Turkey, the dowry money is traditionally given by the man’s side, while here a man collects money from women by promising, “I will marry you.” In Greek and Greek Cypriot traditions, the dowry is customarily prepared by the woman’s side. After the Cyprus War, there was also a period when people wrote, talked and joked a great deal about some soldiers — I mean ordinary soldiers, not commanders — allegedly staying there, promising marriage to women in order to collect money, then returning to Turkey and never going back.
Yes, a man who has been deceived this many times has now, most recently, been deceived in the fund as well. That is what made me think of this whole story of deception. So he was deceived in the fund too, because he says he knew nothing about it. Now he is trying to clean it up.
Fine, let us suppose he personally was never involved at all. Let us assume, as I do, that the Erdoğan family received no income from the fund. Let us also suppose that Erdoğan’s circle and relatives did not benefit from movements in the dollar and the euro. And let us accept that he did not know what his former minister and deputy party chairman were doing either.
Then why did you, as head of state, continue to be deceived after Mehmet Şimşek said this last November?
Then there is only one explanation for this whole “I was deceived” matter. Or rather, two:
Stupidity or fraud.
There is nothing else left to say.
