Is it possible to explain the changes that have taken place in European politics in recent years simply by saying that ‘the far right is on the rise’? From Germany to France, from Italy to the Netherlands, and from Austria to Sweden, nationalist, populist and anti-immigration parties have gained a stronger foothold in many countries compared to the past. A significant transformation is taking place in Europe. Whilst right-wing parties are gaining strength, centre-right and even some centre-left parties are also placing issues long championed by the right at the heart of their own political discourse. The question that needs to be asked here is not “Is Europe turning to the right?”, but rather “Is Europe’s political centre shifting to the right?”.
Although Giorgia Meloni’s Fratelli d’Italia in Italy, Marine Le Pen’s Rassemblement National in France, the AfD in Germany, the FPÖ in Austria, the PVV in the Netherlands’s PVV and VOX in Spain may appear similar, but they actually harbour significant differences from one another. The points they share, however, include limiting migration, strengthening national sovereignty, tightening security policies, preserving traditional social values and questioning the powers of the European Union…
Since the wave of migration towards Europe in 2015, migration has moved beyond being merely a humanitarian issue to become one of the central themes of election campaigns. The social integration of refugees, border security, irregular migration and, in some European countries, rising crime and security concerns have become key issues influencing voters’ political choices. It is at this point that right-wing populist parties have offered simple and direct answers to the public’s concerns.
What were the right-wing parties’ promises?
Tighter borders, less migration and a stronger nation state.
The response from centrist parties, however, was often more complex and cautious. It is precisely for this reason that right-wing parties gained a significant advantage by claiming to articulate voters’ everyday concerns more clearly than other parties.
Is it correct to attribute the rise of the right in Europe solely to immigration? The answer is, of course, no…
Economic and social unrest has increased in Europe in recent years. The cost of living, energy prices, housing costs, young people’s difficulties in finding work, and concerns about the future of the welfare state have fuelled dissatisfaction with traditional political parties. Add to this a decline in trust in political institutions, and the result is clear.
Doesn’t the success of right-wing populist parties stem from their provision of simple answers to problems that appear complex, rather than the solutions long offered by centrist parties in response to these issues? Europe is increasingly debating the question: ‘What sort of society do we want to live in?’ Taking into account the influence of social media, we must also factor in the security concerns raised regarding the future of the European Union as a further driver of the rise of right-wing populist movements.
The fundamental idea of the European Union is based on sharing national sovereignty in certain areas through common institutions. Yet nationalist right-wing parties often advocate for “stronger nation states and less interference from Brussels”.
For this reason, the rise of the right in European politics is not merely a matter of immigration or the economy. It is also a debate about what kind of political structure Europe should have.
However, it would be incorrect to view right-wing parties as a single bloc. Whilst some advocate a complete breakaway from the European Union, others wish to remain within the Union whilst demanding that powers be returned to the nation states. These differences could lead to significant conflicts regarding the future of the European right. There is another crucial point to bear in mind here.
It is not correct to label every right-wing voter in Europe as a ‘far-right voter’. One voter may wish to restrict immigration but still defend democratic institutions. Another may want to see the European Union’s powers reduced but may not wish to abandon liberal democracy.
It is therefore necessary to distinguish between the ‘right’ and the ‘far right’.
However, the opposite mistake must not be made either. Not every party that comes to power through democratic elections can automatically be regarded as posing no risk to democratic values. The real issue here is whether fundamental principles such as the rule of law, the separation of powers, freedom of the press, minority rights, independent institutions and democratic competition are being upheld. For this reason, when assessing the rise of the right in Europe, one must look not only at parties’ economic or immigration policies, but also at their relationship with democratic institutions.
To understand the rise of the right, it is also necessary to examine the problems faced by the European left.
For many years, social democratic parties in Europe served as the primary political representatives of the working class. However, with the transformation of the economy, the decline of industry, globalisation and shifts in the electorate, the ties between these parties and their traditional supporters have weakened. It is particularly striking that a section of the working class, feeling economically insecure, has turned towards right-wing populist parties. This situation demonstrates that the classic political equation of ‘working class = left’ can no longer be relied upon in any country. Today’s voters may demand greater state support on economic issues whilst holding more conservative views on cultural matters. Alternatively, they may hold liberal economic views whilst supporting tough policies on immigration. Consequently, the old left-right divide has become increasingly complex.
It would be incorrect to view the situation facing Europe as an inevitable process moving in a single political direction. Whilst there are countries where right-wing parties are on the rise, there are also those where they are in decline. Voter behaviour can vary depending on economic conditions, immigration figures, government performance and countries’ historical experiences. For this reason, it may be premature to say that “Europe has now turned completely to the right”.
However, there is another reality: the agenda of European politics has also shifted.
Migration, border security, national sovereignty, identity, security and cultural values are now at the heart of European politics. And for a long time, this agenda has been shaped by right-wing populist movements.
Consequently, it is insufficient to interpret the political transformation in Europe solely through the lens of who wins and who loses at the ballot box. The real transformation becomes apparent in the questions politics asks and the answers it deems ‘normal’.
Perhaps what is unfolding in Europe today is not, in the classical sense, a ‘march of the right to power’, but rather a harbinger of a deeper transformation. Right-wing parties may be the most visible actors in this transformation. The real struggle, however, will centre on who can address the electorate’s genuine economic, social and cultural concerns without compromising democratic values.
Is Europe truly turning to the right, or is the political centre – which has been in power for years – disintegrating because it can no longer respond to the electorate’s changing world? The answer to this question will determine not only Europe’s political landscape but also the kind of society it wishes to be.
