Seyhan Uludag
Cemil Tugay’s move to the AKP did not surprise me. I did not wait for Erdoğan to pin the party badge on him before criticising him. In my earlier articles, “Where Shamelessness Becomes Institutionalised: Attendance Fees” and “The Name of Social Fascism in Izmir: Demand Your Rights and You Will Meet the Gas”, I had already questioned the political ethics now being debated again, through his treatment of workers. To me, who a politician is becomes clear first through whose interests he uses his authority to serve, before the values he recites from a podium. I had looked at where he stood in relation to the workers. Today, I look from the same standpoint.
To me, the badge pinned on 7 October is not a fresh start that erases the past; it is a political choice that requires us to reassess the approach to administration I had already criticised. A few sentences about serving the public cannot settle the account for that choice. The mayoralty is not a personal fortune that its owner can carry wherever he pleases. It is a public office won through the votes of a city. Whoever holds that office cannot disregard the political expectations behind the support he received.
The mandate given by voters is not the mayor’s personal title deed. Anyone who packs the will expressed at the ballot box into the luggage of his own political journey and carries it to another party must answer to the electorate. Of course a person can change his views. But the freedom to change one’s views does not create a right to take along the votes cast against those views. Political ethics begins precisely here: do you bear the cost of your own decision, or do you make those who trusted you pay it?
This was the issue I addressed in my earlier articles. I questioned how privileges at management level were defended while workers’ livelihoods became an item in a savings calculation. I examined the thinking behind the management of municipal companies and why labour was treated as an expense. The question I raised under the heading of attendance fees went beyond the name of a payment: when public resources were distributed, who was protected and who was asked to make sacrifices? Are we supposed to forget that question when judging the political morality of the mayor who has now changed parties?
In the life of someone who has been dismissed, the word “savings” is not abstract. It means rent that cannot be paid, medical treatment postponed, being unable to meet a child’s needs. As a line disappears from a management report, a household loses some of its sense of a future. This is where the claim to socially responsible local government is tested. An approach that presents the devastation experienced by workers as an administrative necessity and expects them to be patient renders the social cost of its own decisions invisible. My objection was to that invisibility.
That is why I will not reduce the issue today to the sentence, “He was elected for the CHP and switched to the AKP.” That sentence describes the political change that has taken place; it does not convey the entirety of my criticism. I criticised him when he was wearing the CHP badge too. I did not accept his election for an opposition party as a reason to refrain from questioning his treatment of workers. I did not tie my political loyalty to a mayor’s office. My yardsticks were workers’ rights and public responsibility.
Those expressing surprise today also have questions to ask themselves. Why are an officeholder’s political ethics discussed only when he changes parties? Why is the same attention not paid when workers protest? Does an approach to administration that is overlooked as long as someone remains in one’s own party become a problem only when he joins another? If the issue is principle, that principle must apply to everyone. Workers’ rights are not an item to be postponed in the calculations of internal party politics.
My earlier articles are not evidence that I knew this switch would happen. Knowing who will join which party and when is one thing; recognising the moral problem in a politician’s practices is another. I did the latter. I wrote my objections to Tugay’s political ethics before today’s badge existed. Returning to my earlier texts, this is what I am saying: there was no need to wait for him to change parties before beginning to ask these questions.
Joining the AKP is his own decision. But voters also have the right to object to that decision being presented as though it had been taken on behalf of the people of Izmir. Izmir’s political will cannot be relabelled through one person’s choice. The people of the city cannot be considered to have automatically changed parties in their mayor’s wake. Holding on to the office does not mean still holding all the trust that made that office possible.
Cemil Tugay wears a new badge today. My questions remain: what responsibility did you assume towards the workers? What did you promise those who elected you? How do you explain today’s decision in relation to those promises? Political ethics cannot be built by evading these questions and taking shelter in the shadow of a powerful podium.
For me, this is not about the comfort of saying, “I told you so.” Being proved right does not make good the loss suffered by someone who has lost their job; it does not restore voters’ broken trust. It is about opposing the reproduction of the same blindness. Challenging the surprise shown when the badge changes by those who would not listen when workers were speaking.
My judgement was not made at the sight of the new badge. It was formed by his stance towards labour. Today his party has changed; the standpoint from which I demand accountability remains the same.
